Former Lecturer Secures Substantial Compensation After NHS Error
When Tim Joplin of Dudley, West Midlands, was admitted to Russells Hall Hospital in March 2003, doctors initially diagnosed the cause of his neck and shoulder pain as a pulled muscle brought about by DIY. Despite complaining of worsening pain over the duration of his five-day stay in hospital, the 58-year-old former lecturer and musician was largely ignored as doctors failed to accept any alternative diagnosis to muscular strain. After Mr Joplin’s condition rapidly worsened, the patient was transferred to Queen Elizabeth hospital in Birmingham. A subsequent MRI scan revealed that Mr Joplin was actually suffering from an abscess that was compressing his spinal cord.
Doctors at the Queen Elizabeth hospital carried out emergency surgery to drain the abscess in hope of relieving Mr Joplin’s symptoms and avoiding lasting spinal damage; however, the father-of-two is now paralysed in both arms and legs. Speaking via his legal team, Mr Joplin said: “The encounter I had at Russells Hall Hospital in March 2003 changed me from being a socially skilled individual and useful member of my family, to complete dependency and in almost constant pain. I now want others to realise that they should not be complacent when seeking help from the NHS.”
Accident claims involving medical errors are relatively common in the UK, with many such personal injury claims arising after treatment has fallen woefully short of expected standards. Failing to accurately diagnose a condition is not in itself an act of clinical negligence but, depending on the circumstances of a case, it could contribute towards legal action. Under established principles of negligence law, doctors are liable for any injury or illness they cause if they have failed to reach the standard expected of a responsible body of medical opinion. In the present case, it could hardly be argued that doctors at Russells Hall Hospital acted reasonably in failing to investigate Mr Joplin’s condition further.
Following a seven-year legal battle, The Dudley Group of Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust agreed to pay Mr Joplin £825,000 in an out-of-court settlement. A spokesperson for the trust said: “It [the trust] accepts that there were lessons to be learned and certain systems rectified in order to protect other patients in the future. We are very pleased that a financial settlement has been reached and hope that this will provide financial security to Mr Timothy Joplin and his very caring family in the future.”
After claiming that no amount of money could fully compensate the injuries he had sustained, Mr Joplin warned others of blindly trusting the NHS. Mr Joplin said: “Numerous polite inquiries were made to the staff expressing concerns about my care and pointing out my deterioration, but none of these was addressed… everyone should be vigilant when [they are] an in-patient and family and friends must be prepared to complain and complain again loudly and clearly if they have any concerns.”
Mr Joplin’s advice ought not to be discounted by those admitted to hospital. Although the standard of care provided by NHS staff is often very good, acts of clinical negligence can produce devastating results, as evidenced by Mr Joplin, who is now confined to a specially adapted wheelchair and requires round-the-clock assistance. It is also worth noting that the size of Mr Joplin’s compensation award may seem large but, after necessary expenses and loss of earnings are factored in, not to mention a reduction in his quality of life, this is far from the case.